Which mortar for old Chicago brick: Type N, O, S or lime?
The mortar for old Chicago brick should be softer and more breathable than the brick itself, which on pre-war buildings usually means Type N, Type O or a lime mortar, not Type S or a cement-rich patch mix. Chicago common brick is soft. Joints that are harder than the brick push the stress and moisture into the brick faces, which then pop off. Here's how to choose.
- Mortar is the sacrificial part of a wall: it should wear out before the brick.
- Pre-war Chicago common brick is soft and porous; it needs soft, breathable mortar.
- Type S and portland-heavy patches are a common cause of spalled old brick.
- Match the original in strength, color, sand and joint profile, not just color.
The one rule: mortar should be weaker than the brick
A brick wall moves a little with temperature and moisture, and water gets into it in every storm. When the mortar is softer and more permeable than the brick, small movements crack the joints, not the bricks, and water dries out through the joints. Every few decades you replace the joints and the brick carries on. Reverse that relationship and the brick takes the damage. The U.S. National Park Service's Preservation Brief 2 on repointing makes the same point for historic masonry.
Chicago common brick vs face brick
Most pre-war Chicago buildings use two kinds of brick. The street front gets harder, denser face brick in deliberate colors. The sides, back and interior wythes are Chicago common brick: made from local clay, fired softer, and varying from salmon pink to buff and orange. Common brick is porous and relatively weak, which is perfectly fine as long as the mortar around it is softer still.
Mortar types compared
ASTM C270 defines mortar types by strength. From strongest to weakest: M, S, N, O, then lime mortars below that.
| Mortar | Character | Where it belongs |
|---|---|---|
| Type M | Strongest, high cement | Below-grade and heavy structural work. Not for old brick. |
| Type S | High strength | Below grade, retaining walls, some modern hard brick. Too hard for soft common brick. |
| Type N | Medium strength, the general-purpose mix | Most above-ground walls on 1910s–60s buildings, face brick, postwar houses. |
| Type O | Low strength, high lime | Pre-war soft brick on sheltered walls; interior and protected work. |
| Lime mortar (NHL or lime putty) | Softest, most breathable | 19th-century buildings, very soft brick, landmark work. |
How we choose the mortar for a wall
- Look at the brick: common or face, hard or soft, any spalling already.
- Look at the original mortar where it's still sound: color, sand size, how hard it scratches, whether it looks lime-rich.
- Look at earlier repairs: hard grey patches with chipped brick around them tell us what not to do.
- Consider exposure: a chimney top or parapet cap gets a slightly more durable mix than a sheltered wall, but never harder than the brick.
- Check review requirements: landmark buildings may require a lime mortar or a documented match. See our permit guide.
The damage we see most often in Chicago is common-brick side walls that someone repointed with a hard, grey, cement-rich mix in the last few decades. After a few winters the brick faces start to flake off along every joint. Fixing it means grinding out the hard mortar carefully, replacing the worst brick and repointing with a softer mix. Sometimes that costs more than the original job. See brick repair.
Matching color and texture
Color comes mostly from the sand, not just the pigment. We mix small test batches with different sands, add pigment only if needed, let them cure for several days (wet mortar is always darker), and compare against the wall in daylight. The joint profile, whether concave, flush, struck or raked, matters as much as color to how a wall looks.
Sand, lime and why bagged mortar sometimes isn't enough
Old Chicago mortar often has a coarser, warmer sand and visible bits of lime than modern bagged mortar. Bagged mixes use fine, uniform sand and come out grey and smooth, which stands out on a century-old wall even if the strength is right. For visible walls we mix from separate ingredients: masonry cement or portland and lime in the right proportions for the type, plus a sand chosen to match the color and grain of the original. On landmark work, a mortar analysis of the original can be done by a lab when review calls for it.
Quick answers
More: how we tuckpoint, greystone and landmark restoration, and our Oak Park page for historic-district work.
More Field Notes
Free estimate
Let us look at the wall before you pay for the whole thing
Three details and we'll call to set a time. We look at the joints, the bricks, the lintels and the chimney, then send a written price.
Rather talk it through? Call us.