Signs you need tuckpointing: check your own wall
Signs you need tuckpointing are easy to check yourself: joints recessed more than about 1/4 inch behind the brick face, mortar that crumbles when you scratch it with a key, open gaps, and loose or cracked bricks. Tick what you see in the checker below and it will tell you whether you're looking at a this-year repair or a wall to watch. It takes about ten minutes with a key and a flashlight.
We built this page because most people calling us can't tell whether their wall is fine, needs touch-ups, or needs real work. They're also often being told different things by different contractors. Here's how to judge it yourself before anyone comes out.
How to inspect your wall in ten minutes
- Pick a dry day. Wet mortar looks darker and sounder than it is.
- Start with the worst side. In Chicago that's usually the west or north wall, or whichever side takes the wind off the lake.
- The key test. Drag a house key firmly along a few horizontal joints at chest height. Sound mortar barely marks. Failing mortar scratches out as sand.
- Measure the recess. Put a coin or the key edge in the joint. If the mortar sits more than about 1/4" behind the brick face, water is sitting on that ledge.
- Look up. Use binoculars for the top few courses, window heads, the parapet and the chimney. They're always in worse shape than the bottom of the wall.
- Check inside. Look at the plaster on the inside of the exterior walls, especially below windows and next to the chimney.
- Take photos. Date them. Comparing next spring's photos with this year's is the best way to tell if something's moving.
The signs, explained
Recessed and sandy joints
This is ordinary wear. Mortar weathers back a little each year. Once it's recessed past about 1/4" or crumbles under a key, it's holding water instead of shedding it. That's the point where tuckpointing is due, and the cheapest point to do it.
Open gaps, cracked joints and plants
Gaps and cracks let water straight into the wall. Plants growing from joints mean the joint has held soil and water long enough to sprout something. Both mean that section is past due.
Loose, cracked or flaking brick
When the brick itself is failing, the repair becomes brick replacement plus repointing. Flaking faces (spalling) on old soft brick often mean an earlier repair used mortar that was too hard, or the wall was sealed or painted.
Cracks stepping up from windows
Often a rusting steel lintel lifting the brick. Repointing won't fix that crack; see lintel replacement.
Damp plaster inside
Water has made it through the wall. Trace the source (joints, chimney, parapet, gutters, window flashing) before repairing plaster. Our post on why brick walls leak walks through how.
Where to look first on a Chicago building
| Spot | Why it fails early |
|---|---|
| Chimney above the roof | Exposed on all sides, plus warm, damp exhaust inside. See chimney repair |
| Parapet and coping | Exposed on both faces and the top. See parapet repair |
| Below gutters and downspouts | Concentrated water every rain |
| Under window sills | Water runs off the sill onto the same joints |
| Bottom 2–3 feet | Splash-back, snow piled against the wall, de-icing salt |
| Gangway side walls | Shaded and slow to dry |
| Front steps and wingwalls | Horizontal surfaces holding water and salt. See front steps |
What isn't a problem (yet)
- Fine hairline cracks on a sheltered wall that aren't growing.
- Slight color differences between old repairs and original mortar.
- A little efflorescence after a very wet spring that brushes off and doesn't come back.
- Mortar that's slightly recessed but hard under a key.
If that's all you're seeing, save your money and look again next spring. When you do need work, the cost guide shows what to expect.
Questions
How deep can mortar erode before it needs tuckpointing?
Once joints are recessed about 1/4 inch or more behind the brick face, or the mortar crumbles when scratched, the joint is no longer shedding water well and is due for repointing.
Can I just look from the ground?
For walls up to one story, yes. For upper floors, chimneys and parapets, binoculars help, but those areas usually wear faster than what you can reach, so assume they're worse than the bottom of the wall.
More Field Notes
Free estimate
Ticked more than a couple of boxes?
Send us your address and what you found. We'll come look and give you a written plan, including what can wait.
Rather talk it through? Call us.